Click to Read Bio

Angela R. Kelley, CPA, CGMA

Chief Financial Officer

Since 2003

(513) 677-3100 x100

Ball State
University Graduate

Read Bio
(513) 677-3100 x100
Since 2003

Angela R. Kelley, CPA, CGMA

Chief Financial Officer

Angela R. Kelley currently serves as Chief Financial Officer for Cooperative Business Services LLC. Angela has over 25 years of accounting experience with public accounting firms, large corporations, and the CUSO. Angela has worked for CBS since the company began in 2003.

As Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Angela is responsible for the financial reporting and human resource functions of Cooperative Business Services LLC. In addition, Angela leads and manages many special projects as it relates to the growth and continued development of the company. Angela was a finalist for the Chief Financial Officer of the Year in the small private companies category for 2013 and 2014.

Angela is a licensed Certified Public Accountant, a member of the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, the Ohio Society of Certified Public Accountants, and a Certified Global Management Accountant. Angela has a Bachelor’s of Science degree in Accounting from Ball State University.

Click to Read Bio

Daisy K. Shafer

Chief Operating Officer

Since 2006

(513) 677-3100 x106

Wright State
University Graduate

Read Bio
(513) 677-3100 x106
Since 2006

Daisy K. Shafer

Chief Operating Officer

Daisy K. Shafer currently serves as Chief Operations Officer for Cooperative Business Services (CBS). Daisy has worked in the financial services industry since graduating in June 2003 from Wright State University with a B.S. in International Business. Daisy's background includes over 2 successful years of service in consumer lending for MidUSA Credit Union and over 10 years of commercial lending experience with CBS.

As Chief Operations Officer, Daisy is responsible for managing the Finance and Audit departments, reconciling accounts, assisting with all CBS audits, and preparing 1098/1099 tax forms. Under her direction, the Finance team handles accounts payable, accounts receivable, good faith monitoring, loan maintenance, loan servicing, loan funding, participation agreements and reporting. The Audit team handles pre and post-closing file audits, mortgage releases, UCC monitoring, vendor due diligence, confirmations and construction loan management

Kathy Dinan

Vice President

Since 2010

(513) 677-3100 x114

Pennsylvania State
University Graduate

Jennifer Scheper

Paralegal II / Internal Audit

Since 2012

(513) 677-3100 x124

Northern Kentucky
University and Beckfield
College Graduate


Mary Moran

Loan Servicing Specialist

Since 2013

(513) 677-3100 x125

Joanna Greeson

Accounting Clerk

Since 2014

(513) 677-3100 x122

Wilmington
College Graduate

Christy Barlow

Finance Administrator

Since 2015

(513) 677-3100 x130

University of
Phoenix Graduate